the good:
Taylor - he sang Easy by The Commodores. I thought he was pretty great. He's such a strange guy, but he can sing. he needs to settle down a little bit and stops with the "whoos" and why did he keep saying toboggan? did he mean to say toque?
Elliott - he sang Moody's Mood for Love by Stevie Wonder. he's good. very, very good. very hard to look at, though.
Ace - he sang If I'm Not Made For You by Daniel Bedingfield. If he wasn't sooooo easy on the eyes, I might have put him in the meh category last night. he was good. he wasn't great. Falsettos are a no-no in my book, so Ace, honey, stay away from them. mmm...ace in a beanie=HOT.
Gedeon - he sang Change Is Gonna Come by Sam Cooke. He was great, i thought. "funny little thing" ha!
Chris - he sang Hemorhage by Fuel. He's so freakin' good. dude. can. rock.

the meh:
Kevin - he sang Heard It Through the Grapevine by Marvin Gaye. poor kid. being compared to Chicken Little after he just got through calling himself a sex symbol? He sang it well, but he can't dance for shit, and there was no soul to his singing. it just was. and that's not good enough.
Will - he sang Lady by Kenny Rogers. That was actually pretty good, if a little boring. Guarini? seriously?
Bucky - he sang The Thunder Rolls by Garth Brooks. In his element, but very boring. and Buky? Kellie's already got the "hick out of water" thing down. it's hers, buddy. find something else.

the bad:
Sway - he sang Overjoyed by Stevie Wonder. I actually didn't hate it as much as the judges. but that's a really hard song to sing...perhaps he should have gone slightly safer?
David - he sang The Way You Look Tonight by Frank Sinatra. I love this song. and he butchered it. this is supposed to be his thing, and he couldn't really even pull that off. two words. John. Stevens.

my pick for the boot: Sway and David.
question. what was going on with Will and Ryan at the end there?? was Ryan actually UNDRESSING him?